Certificate 006

Chapter Six: The Map Redrawn

These are the sources the Kool-Aid Laboratory used to examine this chapter. Every one is public. Check them yourself.

Want the plain-English verdict and the full laboratory report for this chapter? Those are in Who's Drinking the Kool-Aid? — The Official Research Companion. Get the Companion →

#1 Scholarly / institutional

Supreme Court of Ohio — the redistricting rulings of the 2021–2022 cycle

, invalidating five state legislative plans and two congressional maps under the Ohio Constitution's anti-gerrymandering provisions (e.g., Adams v. DeWine, 2022-Ohio-89, Jan. 14, 2022; League of Women Voters of Ohio v. Ohio Redistricting Commission, 2022-Ohio-789 and 2022-Ohio-1235; Neiman v. LaRose, 2022-Ohio-2471). Timeline (Brennan Center): Congressional map ruling (Court News Ohio):

#2 Scholarly / institutional

U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio — Gonidakis v. LaRose (May 2022)

— ordered the state to use a legislative plan the Ohio Supreme Court had already rejected, because the election calendar left no timely lawful alternative. Case overview:

#4 Scholarly / institutional

U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama (three-judge panel) — rejection of Alabama's 2023 remedial congressional plan (Sept. 5, 2023), Milligan v. Allen, No. 2:21-cv-01530-AMM.

The panel found the state failed to provide the required additional opportunity district and appointed a special master to draw a lawful map. Case history:

#5 Scholarly / institutional

Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County, Maryland — Szeliga v. Lamone (March 25, 2022).

Judge Lynne Battaglia, in a 94-page ruling, struck the 2021 Democratic congressional map as an unconstitutional "extreme" partisan gerrymander under the Maryland Constitution; a remedial plan was enacted shortly after. Case page: Coverage:

#6 Scholarly / institutional

Illinois — the 2021 Democratic congressional map (Public Act 102-0670)

, cited as the Democratic-controlled counterpart drawn to protect and expand the party's advantage. Background: